Feeling helpless and hopeless, children sometimes voice crushing self-criticisms that pierce through our hearts as parents or caretakers. Phrases like “I cannot do anything right!” or “No one likes me!” echo with a painful intensity, leaving us grappling with how to respond.
Our instinct is to counter these statements immediately, reassuring our children with declarations of their worth and uniqueness. “That’s not true, Sweetie!” we protest, eager to dispel their self-doubt.
Yet, despite our best intentions and earnest efforts to uplift them, our children’s self-esteem remains elusive. The more we affirm their value, the more vehemently they deny it, entrenched in their belief of being “the absolute worst kid in the whole world.” Despite our heartfelt pep talks, their low self-esteem persists, seemingly impervious to our reassurances.
In this blog post, we delve into the intricacies of children’s self-esteem psychology, exploring why simple affirmations may not suffice in bolstering their sense of self-worth.
By understanding the underlying mechanisms of self-esteem development, we can equip ourselves with effective strategies to nurture healthier self-perceptions in our children.
Why does self-esteem matter?
We’ve been repeatedly reminded of the importance of self-esteem in children’s development. The prevailing notion is that children with a positive self-image are more likely to approach new challenges confidently, take pride in their abilities, and be resilient in the face of setbacks.
With a healthy dose of self-esteem, we believe that children can navigate through academic, social, and familial spheres with greater ease.
Conversely, it’s widely believed that children with low self-esteem face numerous obstacles. We believe that they harbor doubts about their worthiness and fear rejection from others. We think that they may withdraw from social interactions, convinced of their unworthiness of acceptance.
Worse yet, we fear that low self-esteem renders our children vulnerable to mistreatment as they struggle to assert themselves and set boundaries. We believe they will succumb to defeat easily, avoiding challenges altogether out of fear of failure.
But amidst these widely held beliefs, it’s crucial to question: is there empirical evidence supporting these assertions? Let’s take a look.
Do we truly need to love ourselves?
The notion that self-love is a prerequisite for a fulfilling life is a common refrain in self-help literature and inspirational anecdotes. However, let’s consider how many individuals genuinely stand before a mirror and declare, “I love myself!”?
The idea that high self-esteem guarantees success and happiness has been pervasive. Yet, research conducted by Roy Baumeister and his colleagues at Florida State University challenges this notion.
In a comprehensive review, Baumeister et al. (2003) found no direct correlation between high self-confidence and academic achievement, nor does it serve as a deterrent against risky behaviors such as substance abuse or premature sexual activity.
Furthermore, elevated self-esteem doesn’t necessarily translate into healthier interpersonal relationships. Despite the intuitive appeal of the belief that children who feel better about themselves will excel in life, empirical evidence suggests otherwise.
As we delve deeper into the intricacies of self-esteem and its impact on various aspects of life, we’re confronted with the complexities and nuances that defy simplistic notions of self-love as a panacea for life’s challenges.
Are parents responsible for low self-esteem?
While parents may not bear sole responsibility for their children’s self-esteem, their influence undoubtedly plays a significant role. Constant praise from parents about their children’s virtues—intelligence, beauty, perfection—can instill a sense of unwavering self-worth in them. However, this relentless focus on bolstering self-esteem can inadvertently lead to adverse outcomes.
Consider a scenario where a student harbors fears of underperforming on a test. A healthy response would involve proactive measures such as early preparation, seeking guidance from teachers, and thorough review of course material. Yet, if the student’s primary concern revolves around preserving their self-confidence, they may adopt avoidance tactics. Rather than confronting potential challenges head-on, they procrastinate studying until the last minute.
In the aftermath of poor performance, the student shields their self-esteem by attributing their failure to external factors—”I didn’t have enough time to study!”—thus absolving themselves of accountability. Jennifer Crocker of the University of Michigan identifies numerous self-defeating strategies employed to safeguard self-confidence, including cheating, dishonesty, deflecting blame, and responding defensively to criticism.
The pursuit of preserving a positive self-image can inadvertently breed a culture of deceit, avoidance, and misplaced blame. By prioritizing the appearance of success over genuine growth and learning, individuals may inadvertently cultivate maladaptive behaviors that undermine their long-term well-being.
Inevitably, despite our well-intentioned efforts as parents to instill self-esteem in our children, the unintended consequence often unfolds: a belief system emerges wherein children feel the need to constantly measure up to the inflated value we’ve bestowed upon them.
This discrepancy between perception and reality sets the stage for inevitable disillusionment. As children encounter setbacks and failures, the chasm between their perceived self-worth and their lived experiences widens, eventually leading to the erosion of self-esteem.
In our quest to shield our children from self-doubt, we inadvertently pave the path to its emergence, highlighting the delicate balance required in nurturing genuine self-esteem amidst life’s inevitable challenges.
Should we try to build our child’s self-esteem?
Given the evidence that the pursuit and protection of self-esteem often yield adverse outcomes, one might question the value of emphasizing self-confidence altogether. However, abandoning the notion of self-esteem entirely would be misguided.
Extensive research indicates that low self-esteem constitutes a significant risk factor for various mental health issues, including depression and disordered eating behaviors. Studies, such as those conducted by Ulrich Orth, underscore the critical role of self-confidence as both a precursor and predictor of depression across all age groups, from childhood onward.
Moreover, the emotional toll of low self-esteem cannot be overstated. When children harbor negative perceptions of themselves, the resulting anguish can be profound, pervasive, and seemingly inescapable.
While the pitfalls of an overemphasis on self-esteem are evident, it’s essential to recognize that nurturing healthy self-esteem remains a vital aspect of holistic well-being. Rather than striving for unwavering self-confidence at any cost, the focus should shift towards fostering resilience, self-compassion, and a balanced sense of self-worth.
By cultivating a mindset that embraces both strengths and limitations, individuals are better equipped to navigate life’s challenges with grace and authenticity.
What is true self confidence like for children?
Breaking free from the confines of low self-esteem hinges on transcending self-focus. Genuine self-confidence transcends the need for constant validation or reassurance. It’s not about believing oneself to be inherently unique or extraordinary; rather, it’s about relinquishing the incessant query, “Am I good enough?”
Consider the ease and comfort you experience when spending time with a close friend. In their presence, you’re liberated from the relentless self-interrogation—”Does my friend approve of me?” or “Am I meeting their expectations?” Such concerns fade into insignificance as you immerse yourself fully in the conversation or activity at hand.
True self-confidence manifests as an unwavering presence in the present moment. When we shed the habit of self-judgment and immerse ourselves fully in the present, we embrace the freedom to listen, learn, experiment, empathize, and engage authentically with the world around us. It’s a state of being characterized by genuine curiosity, openness, and a willingness to embrace both successes and setbacks as integral parts of our journey.
How can we build our child’s self-esteem?
Substantial research by Richard Ryan at the University of Rochester (Ryan and Deci, 2000) has pinpointed that the key to nurturing children’s self-esteem lies in addressing their fundamental needs for connection, competence, and choice.
- Connection entails fostering meaningful and fulfilling relationships that cultivate a sense of belonging. By nurturing supportive connections within family, peer groups, and communities, children develop a robust sense of identity and belongingness.
- Competence involves promoting a growth mindset that values learning and mastery. Encouraging children to embrace challenges, persevere through setbacks, and celebrate their progress fosters a sense of competence and efficacy.
- Choice empowers children to make decisions aligned with their personal values and interests. Providing opportunities for autonomy and self-expression allows children to assert their agency and develop a sense of ownership over their lives.
Rather than seeking to artificially “enhance” our children’s self-esteem, our goal is to alleviate the intense self-focus that underpins low self-esteem. By guiding them to connect with something larger than themselves—be it meaningful relationships, personal growth, or shared values—we cultivate a sense of purpose and belonging that transcends individual insecurities.
Why do most attempts to build self-esteem fail?
Despite our best intentions, many common methods aimed at boosting children’s self-esteem often backfire. For instance, the straightforward approach of praising children indiscriminately can exacerbate feelings of inadequacy, particularly among those with low self-esteem.
In a study led by Eddie Brummelman at Utrecht University, children who received praise such as “You’re great!” after losing a computer game actually felt more ashamed, especially those with low self-esteem. The discrepancy between the praise received and their perceived performance intensified feelings of worthlessness and inadequacy.
Encouraging children to engage in positive self-talk is another commonly prescribed strategy, yet it can inadvertently worsen their self-esteem. Research conducted by Joanne Wood with college students found that repeating affirmations like “I’m an admirable person” led to worsened moods and increased dissatisfaction with oneself among those with low self-esteem. Rather than boosting self-esteem, such positive affirmations served to reinforce their belief that they were unworthy of love and acceptance.
Furthermore, the notion that success breeds confidence is not universally applicable, especially for individuals with low self-esteem. Instead of basking in their achievements, they often downplay their successes and harbor anxiety about maintaining their performance standards or facing heightened expectations from others. Research by Joanne Wood suggests that individuals with low self-esteem feel more anxious after a victory than after a defeat, viewing success as fleeting and fraught with potential pitfalls.
The underlying flaw in these strategies lies in their emphasis on increased self-focus. By prompting children with low self-esteem to constantly evaluate and compare themselves, these methods inadvertently amplify negative feelings and reinforce a cycle of self-criticism. Ultimately, self-focus exacerbates feelings of inadequacy and diminishes the efficacy of self-esteem enhancement efforts.
Conclusion
In our efforts to bolster children’s self-esteem, we often encounter the paradoxical reality that many conventional strategies prove ineffective or even detrimental. Whether it’s indiscriminate praise, positive affirmations, or the pursuit of success, the common thread among these approaches is an inherent emphasis on self-focus—a tendency that exacerbates feelings of inadequacy and self-doubt.
The pitfalls of self-esteem enhancement strategies underscore the importance of adopting alternative approaches that prioritize connection, competence, and choice. By fostering meaningful relationships, promoting learning and mastery, and empowering children to make choices aligned with their values, we can cultivate a sense of purpose and belonging that transcends individual insecurities.
Moreover, it’s crucial to recognize that self-esteem is not a static state to be attained but rather a dynamic process shaped by our interactions with the world around us. Instead of fixating on bolstering children’s self-esteem through external validation, our focus should shift towards nurturing resilience, self-compassion, and an authentic sense of self-worth.
Ultimately, by shifting our focus away from self-evaluation and towards meaningful engagement with the world, we can create an environment that fosters genuine confidence, empowerment, and well-being in children.
Subscribe to our newsletter!
